thanks for redirecting my question to this forum,,,I have checked the Hoeffler site before and they have a "champion" however it is not the Francois Boltano type,,,,as a layman I am amazed at the lack of info on this designer,,,,this type being in my minds eye ,,,incredibly attractive!!!
I have a sample of Boltana's 'Champion' in the Script Font ID Guide. The reason there is so little about him is that he died young, apparently. I don't think the typeface was ever digitized commercially. [edited by moderator]
Sample from the Script Guide: [edited by moderator]
Well, that crude to propose any pirated version of an design made only as exclusive by the designer who died few years ago, defintely too young. I don't like to see used the term "reviving" when its mostly piracy. Forgive me Mike but its nothing against your good intention to help.
Champion received in 1989 the Morisawa Gold prize...
Today, I'm pretty sure that <href>Adobe Bickham Script</a> is a good remplacement, specially the recent OpenType version.
I understand Jean (and Yves I see the edit you made). I am sorry if that was an offensive thing to do. The font I showed is not making money for anyone else, and I did not point to where I found it, and as far as I could find there was no available version of Francois Boltana's font. Do you know of one?
In the past, when we found a digitized version of a font that was not offered commercially we have shared information about it, so I thought I was not promoting a pirated version.
I can see this is a 'gray' area, and I accept your opinion that in this case, the design is too recent to be 'revived'.
Well, another way to look at this is that trying to stamp out the existing fonts leaves nobody happy. To say that doing so does honor to Francois Boltana is open to argument. I dare say that most of us, were we Boltana now and able to look from our resting place, would MUCH rather see two lovingly made fonts that make available the exquisite Champion to be seen and used than to have our typeface tied up in some copyright limbo or, worse, the copyright holder seeing it as not worth digitizing and having no intent to release a font. Saying otherwise takes a certain measure of arrogance, in my opinion.
If anyone knows who owns the rights to Champion, please speak up so that I might write and urge the creation and release of a nice, better made, truly legitimate font that would, indeed, make everyone happy.
An interesting situation where a commercial foundry might be open to litigation, but a freeware font creator is but a shadow to a spurned widow. Well, the creator of the unnamed fonts duo was far from an amateur; it's almost as if a pro was familiar with this situation ...
In any case, my hope that the nefarious freebie survive is only strenghtened (for the sake of the beautiful script and the designer). I will, however, quit being a thorn in Yves' side about his decision here.
I, too, would have to say that we may agree more often than you imagine. We simply draw the line in the sand at a very different spot. I've been trying to be quiet and helpful only; as much as my inner voice allows, anyway. Cheers.
No problem Mike. This was a very gray area case, so I conferred with JFP about it and decided to remove the rip-off. Now if only somebody decided to release the font, everybody'd be happy.
Who's a thorn in my side? As I said, this is a very gray area case, so I take full responsibility for removing samples, names and links of the suspected rip-off. When in doubt, I'd rather play it safe.
That being said, I'd like to go on record that I respect and appreciate your view on the freeware/shareware community. We may agree more often than you imagine. I also feel your opinions ensure that the debate stays open and interesting. It's just that I have to police this place, so I need to be strict.
24 Jan 2005 — 10:37am
thanks for redirecting my question to this forum,,,I have checked the Hoeffler site before and they have a "champion" however it is not the Francois Boltano type,,,,as a layman I am amazed at the lack of info on this designer,,,,this type being in my minds eye ,,,incredibly attractive!!!
24 Jan 2005 — 11:15am
I have a sample of Boltana's 'Champion' in the Script Font ID Guide. The reason there is so little about him is that he died young, apparently. I don't think the typeface was ever digitized commercially. [edited by moderator]
Sample from the Script Guide:
[edited by moderator]
24 Jan 2005 — 11:32am
Here is a link that shows the works of French type designers. It was the source of the original graphic above.
This was originally linked from one of Luc Devrouye's pages about French Type, but the links were changed.
24 Jan 2005 — 11:33am
Boltana also did Stilla in 1973. (It's incorrectly attributed to Robert Hunter Middleton on that page, unfortunately.)
25 Jan 2005 — 1:31am
Well, that crude to propose any pirated version of an design made only as exclusive by the designer who died few years ago, defintely too young. I don't like to see used the term "reviving" when its mostly piracy. Forgive me Mike but its nothing against your good intention to help.
Champion received in 1989 the Morisawa Gold prize...
Today, I'm pretty sure that <href>Adobe Bickham Script</a> is a good remplacement, specially the recent OpenType version.
25 Jan 2005 — 7:50am
I understand Jean (and Yves I see the edit you made). I am sorry if that was an offensive thing to do. The font I showed is not making money for anyone else, and I did not point to where I found it, and as far as I could find there was no available version of Francois Boltana's font. Do you know of one?
In the past, when we found a digitized version of a font that was not offered commercially we have shared information about it, so I thought I was not promoting a pirated version.
I can see this is a 'gray' area, and I accept your opinion that in this case, the design is too recent to be 'revived'.
25 Jan 2005 — 3:57pm
Does anyone know who owns the rights to this typeface?
26 Jan 2005 — 9:23pm
Well, another way to look at this is that trying to stamp out the
existing fonts leaves nobody happy. To say that doing so does
honor to Francois Boltana is open to argument. I dare say that
most of us, were we Boltana now and able to look from our
resting place, would MUCH rather see two lovingly made fonts
that make available the exquisite Champion to be seen and
used than to have our typeface tied up in some copyright limbo
or, worse, the copyright holder seeing it as not worth digitizing
and having no intent to release a font. Saying otherwise takes
a certain measure of arrogance, in my opinion.
If anyone knows who owns the rights to Champion, please
speak up so that I might write and urge the creation and
release of a nice, better made, truly legitimate font that would,
indeed, make everyone happy.
27 Jan 2005 — 2:08am
After death of Fran
27 Jan 2005 — 2:55am
Aha, thank you for that perspective, Jean.
An interesting situation where a commercial foundry
might be open to litigation, but a freeware font creator
is but a shadow to a spurned widow. Well, the creator
of the unnamed fonts duo was far from an amateur;
it's almost as if a pro was familiar with this situation ...
In any case, my hope that the nefarious freebie survive
is only strenghtened (for the sake of the beautiful script
and the designer). I will, however, quit being a thorn in
Yves' side about his decision here.
27 Jan 2005 — 3:26am
I don't envy you the job, Yves.
I, too, would have to say that we may agree more often than
you imagine. We simply draw the line in the sand at a very
different spot. I've been trying to be quiet and helpful only;
as much as my inner voice allows, anyway. Cheers.
27 Jan 2005 — 7:14am
To shift this topic back to Fran
24 Jan 2005 — 9:53am
The only Champion of which I'm aware is that from Hoefler & Frere-Jones.
Thread moving to the TYPE IDENTIFICATION area
24 Jan 2005 — 10:09am
Paul is looking for a typeface by Francois Boltanos called Champion. Any suggestions?
24 Jan 2005 — 10:44am
do you have a sample which you could post? jpg or gif? this would help. (don't know why i didn't think of this in the first place.)
24 Jan 2005 — 11:23am
Ah. We've had this here before, I remember now. Thanks, Mike.
25 Jan 2005 — 3:26pm
No problem Mike. This was a very gray area case, so I conferred
with JFP about it and decided to remove the rip-off. Now if only
somebody decided to release the font, everybody'd be happy.
27 Jan 2005 — 3:06am
Who's a thorn in my side?
As I said, this is a very gray area case,
so I take full responsibility for removing samples, names and links
of the suspected rip-off. When in doubt, I'd rather play it safe.
That being said, I'd like to go on record that I respect and appreciate
your view on the freeware/shareware community. We may agree
more often than you imagine. I also feel your opinions ensure that
the debate stays open and interesting. It's just that I have to police
this place, so I need to be strict.