Why is the Adobe Caslon Pro line spacing so wonky?

Larry G's picture

Hi everyone,

I'm new to the forums, and I just like fonts, but I'm not a fontographer or any kind of design specialist, I'm a civilian, lol. But I love type, me thinks I must have been a printer in a former life.

I have a question about Adobe Caslon Pro. Does anyone know why the line spacing is so wonky (1.5 or double spaced, not sure which)? There don't appear to be any characters in this font that need to have room made for them, so why by default is there this huge 1.5 or double-spaced gap between lines by default in this font? This example is set at single spacing.

Thanks in advance

Larry

bojev's picture

Not a font problem - it is how whatever program you are using is setting it.

Larry G's picture

I know, I'm just wondering why the designer designed it that way. Is there a single character that takes up a lot of space?

Rob O. Font's picture

No, bojev said it is your composition, not design of the font.

What program are you using to compose the lines you show?

Larry G's picture

OpenOffice Writer, but it displays the same behavior in Paint Shop Pro

(Note cursor size)

Below is an example from text as entered in Jasc (now Corel) Paint Shop Pro

And finally an example from MS Wordpad (same family as Office):

Using Windows 7. Sorry for misunderstanding your earlier comment about it possibly being the program, Bojev. Multiple programs suggest it's the font, but I could be mistaken. I assumed it was a design detail, which is why I posted here. Just curious about this.

I'm aware I can adjust the line spacing myself in the various programs. I'm just wondering why it's different by default than other fonts such as Times New Roman?

Nick Shinn's picture

A little detective work:
In this font, the Bounding Box goes 700 units below baseline, 1002 above. That's 702 units more than the 1000 unit em.
The height accommodates accents above capitals, and is fairly normal.
The depth accommodates some ornaments -- vertical border elements.
The lowest typographic elements (commaaccent) are maximum 277 below baseline.
So the ornaments in the font are responsible for its large line spacing.

bojev's picture

Here is Caslon Pro set at 14pt with 14pt leading and as you can see the ascenders and descenders will touch at this leading. Seems that with proper adjustment of leading you can solve the "problem"

Scott Thatcher's picture

I've run into this problem with OpenOffice and all the Adobe typefaces with ornaments.

st

Larry G's picture

Thank you all, that does solve the mystery for me. :)

Larry

Syndicate content Syndicate content