New to Typophile? Accounts are free, and easy to set up.
I've been looking at digital revivals fairly closely, and am quite struck by the variation in quality. For example, here are three versions of the capital E from Centaur:
I'm not going to say which is which just yet, because I think it's likely to color people's perceptions. It shouldn't be too hard to find signs of autotracing.
Please, typophiles, tell me what you think of these three digitizations, and don't hold back. I'll post the answers tomorrow.