I need a VERY thorough critique

evanmacdonald's picture

Fellow typophiles,

I need a very thorough critique of the following piece..


Here is the criteria for the assignment:
+ Format (7.5 by 10.5 inches)
+ It all must fit on a spread
+ About six images (I have 5)
+ It should represent a possible layout for an entire textbook about typography/type designers/type history

What I would like feedback on:
+ Use of negative/white space (is there enough? Is it interesting?
+ Type color (and I am not talking about the red)
+ Relevance and arrangement of images
+ Use of footnotes, image captions and other secondary test
+ Hierarchy
+ General typographic style/following rules, appropriate glyphs, etc

Some info about my design:
+ its on a 5 column grid.
+ Text is set 9/13 x 13p4 (strange measure, I know) Scala and Scala Sans

Oh, and I have thick skin. Please don't hold back. Prompt feedback would be excellent. (Sorry about the second thread, I just need some feedback quickly)

stchoco's picture

i think it looks decent, I just had a little trouble with the captions, if you're going to put them all on one page maybe you should number the images so people can find the caption just a little bit quicker.

Chris Keegan's picture

Overall nice work. I think you need more space between the deck and the body copy, right now it runs together. Not sure about the flush right alignment on the captions, it gives the impression of being jammed in there next to the body copy, how did it look flush left? I think the 2 images on the right hand page are too large, they are running awfully close to the page edge. The body copy seems a bit tight in places, maybe those 2 columns should be slightly wider?

CGI's picture

The grid can only take you 80% of the way, is what this boils down to. : )

SuperUltraFabulous's picture

If you are doing a piece on Zapf perhaps you should consider using his typefaces.

CGI's picture

Or not. ( Imagine this being a spread in a book )

Syndicate content Syndicate content