Which monitors do you use?

Jennifer's picture

Need a proper size monitor for home — 23 inches or so.
Apple prices make my eyes water.

What would you recommend?

Jennifer's picture

(correcting my own grammar)

Patrick Witmer's picture

I picked up this one not to long ago, not the best by any means but can't beat the price. I have been pretty happy with it.

Cheers

p@

Miss Tiffany's picture

I'm using the new Samsung 23" and am quite happy with it. I use a 2-monitor setup. My laptop serves as my jukebox and chat window.

dementad's picture

I use a 24" Samsung and I'm about to upgrade to the 30". This is my second Samsung monitor and I'm extremely happy with it.

Jennifer's picture

You samsung people, how do you find it for colour fidelity?

sebastian, same question to you with the Dell, about colour, and have you ever thought the ultra sharp was artificially over-sharp? yes no?

thanks

Thomas Phinney's picture

Whenever this stuff gets discussed on the InDesign mailing list, there seems to be a general consensus that the Dell UltraSharp line has outstanding quality at a decent price. At least until recently Dell and Apple used the same suppliers, so you were getting largely the "same" monitor for a big price differential - I assume that's still true, but haven't heard on that point lately.

Personally, I don't want to buy an external monitor whose resolution isn't at least equal to my laptop's built-in screen, so currently that's 1920x1200, which is what the particular Dell linked above has. But for now I'll stick to my old 1600x1200 CRT monitor. It works well enough I can't justify spending the money to replace it, even though a higher-res LCD screen would be HOTT.

Cheers,

T

Paul Cutler's picture

One problem noted with the Dell monitors on the Adobe PS board is that they are wide gamut, making color matching particularly testy for web work.

pbc

Jennifer's picture

Dell seems worth checking out, and perhaps can be calibrated away from weird colour settings.

thanks all.

Paul Cutler's picture

Pretty extensive discussion here on a wide gamut monitor (with plenty of color management thrown in):

http://www.adobeforums.com/webx/.59b4e24b/2

pbc

Jennifer's picture

Thanks Paul. Cartoonish is right. Plus, what a lot of work outlined in the threads. Compared to plugging in an apple display. yikes.

I brought my laptop to Future Shop yesterday and hooked it up, calibrated it as best I could, it was still over-saturated. It wasn't an Ultra Sharp, but I don't know about the Dell idea. Maybe you do get what you pay for, and after working on cinema displays this long, maybe I'll always be bugged by the differences. :(

thanks everyone.

Thomas Phinney's picture

Urm, you need to calibrate a display even it's from Apple, no? At least if color accuracy is important to you.

Cheers,

T

Jennifer's picture

yep, you do. this isn't a mac-pc thing, lets not go there. its more a matter of where I can get respectable equipment around here that isn't apple. since that isn't a type thing, I'll figure it out. :)

typ01134's picture

the apple 23" is a stunning screen and to be honest even in the uk at £400 ish its a pretty fair price.?

ive not come across anything as - plug and play for sharpness and colour.

but i'd avoid the 20" version - we have a couple in the studio and compared to the 23's they are like working in a grubby fishtank.

cheers
J

Jennifer's picture

Solved!!
I am now the owner of 2 Macs! Hee! I just bought the 24" iMac, which has gotten delicious reviews. And now my laptop can be a kitchen computer!

Now to explain it to the husband. :)

"like working in a grubby fishtank"

lol!

dezcom's picture

Patrick,

Does your Acer monitor work on a Mac?

ChrisL

Robert Trogman's picture

I just purchased a 28 inch ViewSonic for my Mac Pro which has a paired 19 inch Samsung monitor. When using InDesign I have plenty of room for workspace and room for all the tools and preference windows. The two monitors work well together.

Jos Buivenga's picture

I'm using an 20" Dell in a (vertical) 2-monitor setup together with my MBP, but I'm thinking about buying an 24" (Apple or Dell). Color isn't that important for me. I only use it for type design.

AGL's picture

The Viewsonic monitors have a good color accuracy.

Pedro Leal's picture

Just got an 24'Imac. It has been a perfect work space!
(i was used to my 17'powerbook, now the iMac screen seems endless)

Ch's picture

i have found samsung color space to be consistently inferior for volumetric 3D work. i would avoid them. apple LCD's look best to my eye but offer too few calibration options. the glossy screen is also a bad idea. go for non-gloss if possible.

see also:

http://typophile.com/node/45278

Patrick Witmer's picture

"Patrick,

Does your Acer monitor work on a Mac?

ChrisL"

Sorry Chris I have never tested it on a mac.

Although I don't see why not, I use a mac at work and we use a hanns G monitor with about the same hook ups and specs. Probably more of a video card question.

p@

Syndicate content Syndicate content