"Book Typography" by Mitchell & Wightman: reviews?

crossgrove's picture

I've just gotten a prospectus for this book from Oak Knoll (who are distributors of the book). The authors' own press (Libanus Press) is the imprint. It appears to be a phenomenally complete manual on book typography. 448 pages, 1000 illustrations of concepts and principles, thorough coverage of all topics related to book design including image/text layout, type selection, variables in type specification, and much more. I admit I am very intrigued by this brochure. Has anyone seen the book firsthand?

Miss Tiffany's picture

Sounds juicy. I hope someone can help. I'm curious too.

jason's picture

I picked up a copy directly from the publisher about 9 months ago and must admit it's a bit of an indulgence; there was something about the girth of the thing and the high production values that appealed to my vanity. The book really is nicely put together, and what it does it does very well; that is, it is ultimately pragmatic in its approach.

The "problem" is that if one has studied one's Bringhurst, with additional readings from, say, Dowdings' Finer Points... and Tschichold's The Art of the Book, with, say, a few dashes of Felici's Complete Manual of Typography, (and every self-respecting book typographer should be reading these texts) then, really, Book Typography won't be as full of useful info as it might be to someone coming in blank.

That said, the book has dedicated chapters on topics not touched by any of the above-mentioned books: basic halftone & 4-colour pre-press, technical details on setting up & designing soft-bound covers & dust jackets, etc. (see below for the TOC). The book also focuses more on the fine details of HOW to accomplish certain typographic principles. Thus, where Bringhurst is perhaps heavier on the theory side, this text is very focused on the practical application; not exactly an application-specific manual, but a fairly clear book typographer's handbook.

One small bug for North American readers is that the (format) dimensions tend to be in metric, rather than imperial (and this coming from a Canadian!); typographic dimensions are, for the most part, in points and picas, but dimensions relating to book/page/sheet size are all metric and/or European (that is, A2, A3, A4 rather than tabloid, legal, letter, etc.).

As I started, the book really is an indulgence, as much (I'm guessing) for the authors in producing the book as it is to own. It's lush, beautiful and well built, and it looks good on the shelf. However, when I'm looking to confirm a principle, it's still Bringhurst that I reach for.

crossgrove's picture

Thanks, Jason. I could see recommending this to students and graphic designers, then. I suppose I'll end up treating myself to a copy....

ben_archer's picture

Hi Carl. I saw the same prospectus;

...wonder what they have to say about drop caps in the forthcoming Oak Knoll title Book Typography: A Designer’s Manual? My head of department just forwarded me the info on it. Judging by the contents listing, Mitchell and Wightman give the topic about four pages.

but I still haven't seen the book itself... you could say that their prospectus is doing exactly what it it's intended to do; whip up a storm of pre-sales anticipation!

The book itself is at

http://www.oakknoll.com/detail.php?d_booknr=92771

although I no longer see the downloadable .pdf prospectus there.

Jason's comment about it being more useful to a complete beginner is probably right on the money. Me, I have no problem with metric page dimensions, so it's good to know that much in advance. I guess I would want to see how it compares against Jost Hochuli & Robin Kinross's Designing books: practice and theory, or even Ari Rafaeli's Book Typography, also at Oak Knoll.

jason's picture

Ben, I have Kinross' book as well, and Hendel's On Book Design, both of which I might have mentioned above. Again, if one has either/both of those titles, the Mitchell and Wightman becomes even more unnecessary. Which isn't to say that it isn't a worthy acquisition.

Here are scans of the TOC:





Ricardo Cordoba's picture

In case anyone's interested in seeing a review from a trade magazine, Grafik had an article about this book in their February 2006 issue (it's not online, sadly).

ben_archer's picture

Ah Jason I thought you might have those other titles; your scans are so much nicer than the T.O.C. Oak Knoll have up on their website. On the basis of this, I'd say it's pretty reasonably priced.

jason's picture

I got my copy directly from Libunus Press. Here's their page: http://www.libanuspress.co.uk/

Linda Cunningham's picture

Thanks for posting the TOC, Jason.

Y'know, from that, it almost looks like EOTS meets CMS and/or (Editing Canadian English, Second Edition: really similar process in the TOC) meets IP's Pocket Pal....

An interesting mixture, but given the price, I'm not convinced it's a worthy purchase.

ben_archer's picture

All that for a mere 35 quid? Wow Linda you must be a tough customer...

It was very interesting for me to see how the Libanus Press have put their website together; clearly it's all about control.

jason's picture

Ben, that 35 quid plus trans-Atlantic shipping adds up to over $100 in Canada.

Linda Cunningham's picture

I'm half-Scots: as Jason mentioned, for $100 here in Canada, I can get most of the books I listed and still have some change left over for a pint or three. :-)

Maurice Meilleur's picture

From the TOC, it looks like what Mitchell and Wightman bring to the table is an integration into the discussion of book design of the nuts and bolts of bookmaking, like getting files and images ready for press, different kinds of bindings and covers, the economics of printing and how that affects book design, etc. (parts 11, 12, 14, 15, and 16).

I don't remember seeing those things discussed in Felici, Bringhurst, Hochuli, or Tschichold, and a look at Hendel and Dowding's TOCs tells me they don't address those things in any systematic way, either. Am I missing something? Speaking as an autodidact in the world of book design, this seems like a superb book to have on the shelf.

Linda Cunningham's picture

But they are discussed in things like International Press' Pocket Pal, which one can often get for free from commercial printers throughout North America, or pay around $20 US for. It's invaluable for the basics of how to get any sort of work off to press: my copy sits next to Bringhurst. ;-)

ben_archer's picture

OK Linda, yours for a pint or three whenever!

Maurice makes a good point about the relevance and orderliness of what's integral to the book; although I'm delighted to see the (often overlooked) content of Part 16, it occurs to me that one could easily spend more than five pages talking about paper & press in this context in the preceeding Part 15.

Jason, (not a qualitative question I grant you) how many words are they putting on the average page here?

Seriously folks, shipping is shipping; to blame the publisher for how expensive it is to get the goods to your door is to confuse the issue. What's to stop any of you ordering from Oak Knoll? Or did you want it discounted from amazon.com to begin with? If I placed an order tomorrow, I would do so knowing the air freight from the UK to NZ would be prohibitive. I hope this wouldn't interfere with my ability to evaluate the worth of the book itself.

jason's picture

As I think I've stressed above, the book is very well produced: the content is comprehensive, the writing clear and practical, the pages well illustrated & nicely composed, the book finely designed & beautifully printed. Perhaps it's notable that I ordered my copy only after seeing a copy first-hand, perhaps not. I certainly don't think this is simply a matter of being lazy or cheap. It's just that as folks invested & in love with typography & book design I assume that many of us have read extensively on the topic, have gathered a handsome collection of books on the topic along side a stack of others hoarded from the library. The result of this, at least on my part, is a certain disappointment when I shell out a good sum of money for the latest publication only to find that there isn't much in it I wasn't already familiar with. This isn't a complaint about the book, or any book, but about the fact that inevitably books on any given topic become repetitive and, at least to some extent, redundant.

There is also the position which places a certain emphasis on "buying locally." This is a somewhat pointless argument in the age of Amazon, and in fact the opposite argument is likely more appropriate: that buying directly from Libanus (as I did) is the only way to get the money to the individual publisher. However, if the information found in a book produced in England can also be found in a book produced in Vancouver...

Linda Cunningham's picture

Good points, Jason, particularly the fact that inevitably books on any given topic become repetitive and, at least to some extent, redundant.

For those of us with groaning bookshelves, it's hard to justify buying yet another book, particularly sight-unseen, that covers already tilled ground.

But if I was just starting out, it certainly covers a lot of ground in one book.

(Ben, you're on for a pint if you're coming to TypeCon.)

Syndicate content Syndicate content