Futura medium

objekt's picture

I've been seeing different versions of Futura Medium; some with very tall ascenders, and some with not so tall ascenders. This goes back to metal versions and continues into the digital realm. Which is what Renner intended? Does the Renner book address this?

Here's tall one
http://www.adobe.com/type/browser/F/P_046/F_FUTU-10005000.html

And a sample of CAPS vs lc ascenders which are not so tall
http://store.bitstream.com/testdrive.php?handle=573&text=CAPSbdfhklt&size=36&View+Text%21.x=48&View+Text%21.y=12

hrant's picture

From what I know the tall one is the original
one, but I think the short is better (I should
say less bad) since it's a display face anyway.

hhp

hrant's picture

I guess so. But what are the chances that somebody who insists on setting text in Futura would go for the tall one?... On the other hand, it could conceivably be a good compromise solution: in a two-man team with a "visual" designer and a "textual" designer, Futura-tall could prevent a war. But still.

hhp

flingford's picture

Hah. This thread is pretty funny. It's like fighting the resurgence of bellbottoms for men--which are much uglier than any cut of Futura.

I recently saw a current annual report designed by Cahan & Associates that used Futura *gasp* for body copy. I was very surprised and disappointed. But with an objective consideration, it's actually quite well done. (I am going to have to find out if it's the tall or short variety. Heh.)

So, by talking about it so much, are we predicting a new popularization of Futura? I hope not. As anyone who's ever worked with a design system based around Futura may agree, it's a very boring font after a considerable length of time.

//joe

anonymous's picture

Chris' (Burke) book has an entire chapter dedicated to the design of Futura. There are original drawings as well. You might find your information there.

Also, I enjoy the spicy remark Hrant. I agree with you, but so many people still use Futura for body. Wouldn't the tall ascenders assist the reader more than short? I mean if someone insists upon using Futura as body?

Syndicate content Syndicate content