Type Battle 29 // Circuit City Logo Redesign

Ngoc Ngo
17.Nov.2008 2.34pm
Ngoc Ngo's picture

It was announced in the news last week that Circuit City, a major US electronics retailer, has filed for bankruptcy protection amid a weak economy. According to CNN, the company plans to keep its remaining stores open through bankruptcy proceedings and encourages consumers to continue shopping at its stores.

Typophiles, how can you as type and/or graphic designers help Circuit City in these pressing times?

// TYPE BATTLE 29

Design a new logo (or logotype) for Circuit City. Extra points for creating additional branded examples to support your design.

Winner take all, no holds barred. May the best designer win.

// REQUIREMENTS

- Image size: 550 width x 400 height. 72 dpi
- Color: We usually stipulate black and white, but not this week!
- Format: JPG or PNG

// ABOUT TYPOPHILE TYPE BATTLES

This is your chance to stretch your type muscles on a weekly basis. You have one week to create and submit your entry. Anyone may submit a design response to the challenge. You may enter as often as you wish. Post anytime. Critiques and comments are welcome throughout the game, from participants and spectators alike. Smack talk is encouraged.

As with any street battle, there is no panel of judges and no prize — only the ability to call yourself the best on the block.

Link directly to this battle: http://www.typophile.com/battle29
Link to the battle directory: http://www.typophile.com/typebattles

rubenDmarkes
17.Nov.2008 2.37pm
rubenDmarkes's picture

Oh boy. xD


Nick Job
17.Nov.2008 3.07pm
Nick Job's picture

When it says "stretch your type muscles on a weekly basis", didn't Type Battle 27 last about 4 months? In fact is that over yet? I don't look much any more because it takes so long to load the page with all the great potential Typophile logos.


Nick Job
17.Nov.2008 3.09pm
Nick Job's picture

Next, how can anyone who uses Gotham have gone to the wall?


dezcom
17.Nov.2008 3.41pm
dezcom's picture

ChrisL


beejay
17.Nov.2008 3.56pm
beejay's picture

clever :)

wonder how it would look if the i-t was the 11?


pica pusher
17.Nov.2008 4.15pm
pica pusher's picture

Let's get this one out of the way:


Joe Pemberton
17.Nov.2008 5.07pm
Joe Pemberton's picture

Pica Pusher, that's hilarious.


dezcom
17.Nov.2008 5.33pm
dezcom's picture

What do you do when the bottom is dropping out?

ChrisL


dezcom
17.Nov.2008 5.35pm
dezcom's picture

Brian,
That kind of 11 reminds me too much of the 9-11 license plates. :-(

ChrisL


Joe Pemberton
17.Nov.2008 5.42pm
Joe Pemberton's picture

I motion that we not allow Chris (dezcom) to post again until he designs a mark/logotype to help them succeed!


dezcom
17.Nov.2008 5.45pm
dezcom's picture

:-(

ChrisL


typerror
17.Nov.2008 5.45pm
typerror's picture

I guess since they are closing so many stores the should be considered a township or village instead of a city : )

Michael


dezcom
17.Nov.2008 7.04pm
dezcom's picture

OK, Joe. This is supposed to help them:

ChrisL


greyjay
18.Nov.2008 12.25am
greyjay's picture

Tried to go with the circuit board schematic vibe while keeping it as simple as possible.

...and here's an afterthought with the double c... I might like it more, but it may look too much like the closed caption logo.


cerulean
18.Nov.2008 2.21am
cerulean's picture

You ideas, GJ, even suggest a business strategy: They could pick up the components market that Radio Shack has abandoned.


timd
18.Nov.2008 3.40am
timd's picture

Talking about getting things out of the way


AGL
18.Nov.2008 4.52am
AGL's picture

I wonder who (what) is going to be next.


j_polo9
18.Nov.2008 9.30am
j_polo9's picture

lol is that the monster from doctor who?


Joe Pemberton
18.Nov.2008 9.39am
Joe Pemberton's picture

Closed Caption uses a CC inside an rounded rectangle TV shape and Creative Commons both use the circle CC mark.


fbrccn
18.Nov.2008 10.42am
fbrccn's picture

a bunch of rather obvious ones:


Pentapus
18.Nov.2008 12.03pm
Pentapus's picture

Circuit City always ripped me off. Its bankrupt because its prices were worse than Best Buy. That said, sorry to anyone who lost work/money from their bankruptcy.


david hamuel
18.Nov.2008 12.15pm
david hamuel's picture

"I have 1 billlllllllion dollars"


Typedog
18.Nov.2008 2.54pm
Typedog's picture

Were broke?


istariskoda
18.Nov.2008 4.12pm
istariskoda's picture

Chuck


Typedog
18.Nov.2008 8.20pm
Typedog's picture

I like the old logo, not even a logo change can save the place.


dezcom
18.Nov.2008 9.02pm
dezcom's picture

ChrisL


dezcom
19.Nov.2008 6.02pm
dezcom's picture

!


Typedog
18.Nov.2008 10.54pm
Typedog's picture

No I think I wont.


SuperUltraFabulous
18.Nov.2008 11.43pm
SuperUltraFabulous's picture

I LoVE the Comic Sans one!!!!!!!


Flanney
19.Nov.2008 5.01am
Flanney's picture


jupiterboy
20.Nov.2008 7.33am
jupiterboy's picture

Running away from the red—probably not wise.


SuperUltraFabulous
19.Nov.2008 5.11pm
SuperUltraFabulous's picture

jupiterboy>>> love that!!! What’s that nice font you are using?


Joe Pemberton
19.Nov.2008 6.05pm
Joe Pemberton's picture

We have a client from Napster (Napster was just acquired by Best Buy) in the office. She got a kick out of Pica Pusher's Best Buy version.


jupiterboy
19.Nov.2008 6.26pm
jupiterboy's picture

[[http://www.vllg.com/Thirstype/ApexNew/mudTyper+Weights/|Apex New]]


Quincunx
20.Nov.2008 10.09am
Quincunx's picture

More lettering than logo. Probably made it a bit too quickly. But oh well :P


dezcom
20.Nov.2008 10.16am
dezcom's picture

It has a friendly look, Jelmar. Why are the caps so tall?

ChrisL


Quincunx
20.Nov.2008 11.57am
Quincunx's picture

Good question ;)

I'll try a version with shorter ones later today.


Quincunx
20.Nov.2008 3.15pm
Quincunx's picture

Maybe more like this then.


dezcom
20.Nov.2008 3.40pm
dezcom's picture

Yes! it interacts better with the i dots as if it were connecting a circuit.

ChrisL


chadengle
20.Nov.2008 3.55pm
chadengle's picture

Flanney.I really like yours something clean about it but I don't think it would really work well for a corporation. I think it is a really clean design maybe for a blog or something!

Nothing is going to save Circuit City so cool Idea I like.


beejay
20.Nov.2008 4.10pm
beejay's picture

jelmar and jupiter boy, liking those!


dogg
20.Nov.2008 4.30pm
dogg's picture

Nobody has explored the "city" in Circuit City yet? C'mon it's a city of circuits!

DOGG : : :


jupiterboy
20.Nov.2008 4.56pm
jupiterboy's picture

^ that depends on how literal you want to be

What is the difference visually, between a subway map and an electronic diagram?


dezcom
20.Nov.2008 5.14pm
dezcom's picture

Then you go for it, DOGG! :-)

ChrisL


pica pusher
20.Nov.2008 6.50pm
pica pusher's picture

Quick sketch. Waiting to see that subway map concept!


pica pusher
20.Nov.2008 6.54pm
pica pusher's picture

Thanks Joe! Can I use you as a reference when I apply to work the Best Buy register? ;)


jupiterboy
20.Nov.2008 7.01pm
jupiterboy's picture

Flanney
20.Nov.2008 8.12pm
Flanney's picture

Thank you for your comments and criticisms Chad, fair call on it not working for a corporation like Best Buy - totally agree. I might have a go at redoing it with that in mind


j_polo9
21.Nov.2008 6.04am
j_polo9's picture

@ pica pusher, I like it.
@ fbrccn, I like the obvious and simple logos. Only they remind me fairly too much of Target.


dezcom
21.Nov.2008 7.02am
dezcom's picture

Actually, if you remember the old Continental Can Co. logo, it will be even more so.

ChrisL


jt_the_ninja
21.Nov.2008 9.11am
jt_the_ninja's picture

I decided maybe they should try the Walmart route...

The green border was an accident from the canvas sizing, but I thought it was funny enough to include it as a variant.

Peace,
JT


SuperUltraFabulous
21.Nov.2008 9.38am
SuperUltraFabulous's picture

Love that, JT!!!!!

Change their slogan to match the new flowery campaign:
“CircuitCity, now in Cinnamon Breeze scent!”


jt_the_ninja
21.Nov.2008 9.45am
jt_the_ninja's picture

Hey, might as well... :þ

Peace,
JT


Typedog
21.Nov.2008 4.54pm
Typedog's picture

@jt_the_ninja

It seems like a soft version of Circuit City, I like the color scheme it is energetic.


Flanney
21.Nov.2008 5.20pm
Flanney's picture

Please don't judge on its ability to work as a properly functioning circuit


SuperUltraFabulous
21.Nov.2008 9.54pm
SuperUltraFabulous's picture

LOVE THAT... is that DIN?


sasapetrova
22.Nov.2008 2.35am
sasapetrova's picture

First try, others will follow.


sasapetrova
22.Nov.2008 4.42am
sasapetrova's picture

The next one.


SuperUltraFabulous
22.Nov.2008 9.52am
SuperUltraFabulous's picture

Okay, I want to see a city of circuits tho. Keep going guys et gals.


Cole
22.Nov.2008 7.59pm
Cole's picture

Jupiterboy-
Why do you think avoiding red is such a bad idea?

I would suggest keeping the red in--or a shade of red--as a secondary or tertiary color in the overall brand.

In times of recession, as we are now, red tends to take on new meaning in the eye of an average American consumer, and as such, red would not be a good choice for a primary color.

For the sake of a re-brand and presenting the consumer with the idea that circuit city isn't completely new (after all, they're still 'circuit city'), keeping red in some way would be advisable. It would certainly help in positioning the brand with longevity in mind- which is something recession-scared consumers highly value.


jupiterboy
22.Nov.2008 8.25pm
jupiterboy's picture

Oh, I imagine red or blue would be the way to go. I was joking a bit as a change like that would presumably be shot down because as A.) to much of a departure, and B.) a color already in use by the major competitor.


Cole
22.Nov.2008 8.50pm
Cole's picture

sasapetrova-
The word 'circuit' is hanging out by itself, completely lost in space. I feel like it should be connected somehow.

jupiter-
I liked your use of the 'i' dots and the representation of a circuit- I think they worked well together. You should try doing the outer box in a shade of red- perhaps a crimson color and leave the text a complementary shade of blue or even gray. Maybe vice versa?


jupiterboy
23.Nov.2008 4.22am
jupiterboy's picture

OKs. Fruit Juicy version for Cole. Note: per previous posts the detail is intended to evoke a subway map as much as a circuit. I realized the similarity and that's what drew me into the competition. Maybe someone can do a better job of bringing this out. Also, I usually like to do something that will work in one color, say a solid and a screen of that solid, for the low end—boxes and such.


sasapetrova
23.Nov.2008 11.39am
sasapetrova's picture

A circuit like logo this time.


jt_the_ninja
24.Nov.2008 5.25am
jt_the_ninja's picture

I think sasapetrova wins...so far.

Peace,
JT


Boros
24.Nov.2008 12.08pm
Boros's picture

Another DIN City

Umm... is the battle over?


Joe Pemberton
24.Nov.2008 5.18pm
Joe Pemberton's picture

A toast! May this battle inject all struggling consumer electronics retailers with prosperity in the coming punch-up of black Friday and the onslaught of the holiday shopping season.


jupiterboy
24.Nov.2008 5.30pm
jupiterboy's picture

Or, to the long overdue consolidation of the consumerist nightmare of too much too cheap too often. May the weak fail and not be bailed out, and may our children not be slaves to our debt.


eliason
25.Nov.2008 7.50am
eliason's picture

jupiterboy, when we go pitch your logo to the CC boys, I'll do the talking, okay? ;-)


jupiterboy
25.Nov.2008 8.06am
jupiterboy's picture

Absolutely. Please keep my mouth shut as much as possible.


SuperUltraFabulous
27.Nov.2008 1.24am
SuperUltraFabulous's picture

I like Boros’s too!

Good job every one.


Cole
15.Dec.2008 2.23pm
Cole's picture

JupiterBoy:
If that logo was on a pack of gum, I'd buy it.

www.dothbrands.com
www.dothbrands.tumblr.com